New Delhi, September 6, 2025 – A diplomatic stir unfolded this week when U.S. President Donald Trump claimed that the United States had “lost India” to China and Russia. The remark, made on Truth Social, immediately grabbed global attention and stirred discussions about the state of India–US relations.
Trump’s Bold Statement
The controversy started when Trump posted that the U.S. had “lost India and Russia to China.” He shared a photo of Prime Minister Narendra Modi alongside Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin, sparking concern among international observers about possible strains in the bilateral relationship.
Modi’s Calm and Diplomatic Response
In a measured response, PM Modi took to X (formerly Twitter), stating:Deeply appreciate and fully reciprocate President Trump’s sentiments and positive assessment of our ties. India and the US have a very positive and forward-looking Comprehensive and Global Strategic Partnership
Trade Tensions in the Background
Adding context, Trump had recently imposed tariffs of up to 50% on Indian imports, citing India’s continued purchases of discounted oil from Russia. While personal rapport between the leaders remains warm, policy differences continue to create friction.
Why This Matters
- Personal Bonds vs Policy – Modi and Trump’s friendship demonstrates that strong diplomatic ties can survive political disagreements.
- India’s Strategic Autonomy – India continues to maintain independent decisions while fostering relations with the U.S.
- Signals of Stability – Friendly public statements by both leaders help reduce diplomatic strain and reassure global partners
The Takeaway
While Trump’s remark initially caused alarm, Modi’s poised response shifted the narrative toward cooperation and positivity. For now, India and the U.S. continue to maintain a strong, forward-looking partnership.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
1. What did Trump mean by saying the US ‘lost India’?
Trump’s comment referred to his perception that India is moving closer to China and Russia, particularly in terms of trade and energy deals. However, it was largely a rhetorical statement and later clarified by Trump himself.
2. How did Prime Minister Modi respond to Trump’s remark?
PM Modi responded calmly on X (formerly Twitter), emphasizing that India–US ties remain very positive and forward-looking. His statement reinforced India’s commitment to maintaining a strong strategic partnership with the U.S.
3. Are India–US relations in trouble?
Despite occasional disagreements, such as trade tariffs, both countries continue to maintain a robust strategic partnership. Modi’s response signals that relations remain stable and cooperative.
4. Why did Trump impose tariffs on Indian imports?
The tariffs of up to 50% were imposed due to India’s continued purchase of discounted oil from Russia. This reflects ongoing trade and policy disagreements, not a complete breakdown in the bilateral relationship.
5. What is the significance of Modi’s response?
Modi’s measured response demonstrates diplomatic maturity, signaling that India values its relationship with the U.S. while maintaining strategic autonomy in international affairs.
6. Will India’s ties with the US affect its relationship with Russia or China?
India continues to balance its foreign policy, maintaining strong ties with the U.S., Russia, and China. Modi’s response emphasizes cooperation without compromising national interests.
People Also Ask (PAA) – India–US Relations & Trump’s Remark
1. Did Trump really say the US lost India?
Yes, Trump tweeted that the U.S. had “lost India and Russia to China,” which created a media stir. He later clarified that he maintains a friendly relationship with PM Modi.
2. How did the world react to Trump’s comment on India?
The comment sparked global headlines and discussions about India–US ties, but Modi’s diplomatic response helped reassure both domestic and international audiences.
3. What are the main issues affecting India–US relations?
Key issues include trade disputes, tariffs on Indian imports, and India’s energy purchases from Russia. Despite these differences, the strategic partnership remains strong.
4. Is Modi worried about Trump’s remarks affecting India–US ties?
No. Modi’s measured response emphasized that India–US ties remain very positive, highlighting cooperation over conflict.
5. Will this affect India’s foreign policy with China and Russia?
India continues to maintain a balanced foreign policy, engaging with the U.S., Russia, and China independently while safeguarding its strategic interests.
6. How does this impact trade between India and the US?
While tariffs on certain Indian imports create short-term friction, both countries continue to engage in trade negotiations and maintain overall economic cooperation.